Decisions · Strategy and governance

Should your loyalty programme serve businesses or consumers

Serve consumers. A loyalty programme earns margin by changing individual behaviour, not by reselling business services. Serve businesses only when those businesses are buying on behalf of identifiable consumers whose behaviour you can track and reward.

The decision

This is not a choice between two customer segments. It is a choice about which unit of behaviour you can actually change with points, tiers and rewards. A loyalty programme works by attaching a personal identity to a repeated purchase and making the next purchase feel cheaper or more valuable to that same person. Consumers have personal memory, personal accounts and personal discretion. Businesses have procurement policies, committees and corporate accounts. The decision is therefore whether your economics depend on changing one person's repeated choice or on changing an organisation's contract terms.

What it costs you

Serving consumers commits you to managing individual data, privacy rights and fraud disputes at scale. The cost is not in points issued but in the operating capacity required to keep member trust. Take an illustrative programme with 80,000 active members. Each data correction request takes 15 minutes of staff time at 20 dollars per hour, so 5 dollars per request. If 2 percent of members request a correction in a year, that is 1,600 requests times 5 dollars, or 8,000 dollars. If the same 80,000 members each spend 600 dollars a year and earn one point per 10 dollars, they earn 60 points each, or 4,800,000 points in total. Valued at 0.01 dollars per point, the annual point liability is 48,000 dollars. The data request cost is 8,000 dollars against 48,000 dollars of point liability, or exactly one sixth. Consumer programmes therefore spend a meaningful share of their reward budget on trust administration, not on rewards, when member rights are taken seriously.

How to decide

Identify the one person whose repeated choice you need to change. If that person has a personal email address, a personal device, and the freedom to choose between you and a competitor on each purchase, serve consumers. If the purchase is signed off by a manager, paid by accounts payable, and the reward would be received by the company rather than the individual, do not build a loyalty programme for that buyer. Use volume discounts, trade credit or a named-account sales incentive instead. The loyalty mechanism only works when the person earning points is the same person who feels the loss of not earning them.

What would change our mind

Our recommendation flips if you can identify a stable individual buyer inside a business who makes the purchase decision personally, receives the reward personally, and can carry that reward identity across employers or suppliers. That condition is rare but testable: if the business buyer has a personal login, redeems points for personal travel or gift cards, and your contract names that individual as the reward recipient, then a business-facing programme can behave like a consumer programme. In every other case, treating a business as the member is just a discount scheme with extra steps.

Related