Analysis
Decisions
The choices a programme owner actually faces, each with the condition that flips it. A decision page states a recommendation and what breaks if you take it.
71 published
- How many tiers should your loyalty programme have
Use two published tiers for nearly every loyalty programme, and add an unpublished recognition tier only when at least one in five active members can…
- How should a co-brand loyalty programme divide the economics
A co-brand programme should divide economics by paying the loyalty brand a fixed cents-per-point transfer price plus a small fixed fee per active…
- How should you allocate market development funds in loyalty
Put at least 80 per cent of market development funds into member-facing earn accelerators and redemption discounts that expire within one billing…
- How should you choose a loyalty issuing partner
Choose a loyalty issuing partner by assigning unredeemed point liability and member data control to the party best able to manage them.
- How should you defend the loyalty programme budget
Defend the loyalty programme budget as a contractual liability, not a marketing line, by accruing for unredeemed points and funding redemptions from…
- How should you design a dealer incentive programme
Design the programme as verified sell-through: reward dealers only when an end customer takes delivery and the sale appears in your point-of-sale or…
- How should you design loyalty for a low-frequency category
For a low-frequency category, do not build a points programme.
- How should you price a loyalty redemption catalogue
Price each redemption at the programme's marginal cost plus a fixed uplift that covers liability and breakage, not at the retail price or a…
- How should you set loyalty earn rates
Set the base earn rate at one point per dollar of revenue, then cut category rates where gross margin is below 20 percent and raise them only with…
- How should you set loyalty tier thresholds
Set tier thresholds at the point where a member's expected incremental contribution margin pays for the extra cost of that tier.
- How to set a point value
Set a point at one cent of redemption value, fixed and published, and set the earn rate from the margin you can fund.
- Should a tier change use a soft landing or hard reset
Use a soft landing for any tier change that reduces value or raises thresholds, provided the tier continues to exist and the old status was earned in…
- Should loyalty accrual be real time or batch
Accrue loyalty points or miles in real time for any programme where a member can view, redeem, or transfer a balance immediately.
- Should loyalty AI decisions be explainable to members
Yes.
- Should loyalty rewards be funded by you or a partner
Fund rewards from your own balance sheet whenever the outstanding liability is small enough to carry without cutting other investment.
- Should loyalty use machine learning, an LLM, or rules
Use deterministic rules for every member-visible accrual, tier, and redemption calculation, because those are liabilities you must be able to audit.
- Should tier qualification roll over
Yes, but only with a cap.
- Should tiers qualify on spend or activity
Tiers should qualify on spend.
- Should you add loyalty benefits to a subscription
Yes, add loyalty benefits to a subscription if you can fund them from existing margin and the benefits reinforce the subscription's own use, such as a…
- Should you add more loyalty tiers when status loses meaning
Do not add more tiers while status has lost meaning.
- Should you align every function before launching loyalty
No.
- Should you allow point transfers
Do not allow open member-to-member point transfers.
- Should you allow promotions to stack
No.
- Should you allow resellers to earn loyalty rewards
Do not allow resellers to earn loyalty rewards on stock bought for resale.
- Should you benchmark against competitor programmes
Benchmark competitor programmes, but only for visible member expectations: how many points a typical transaction earns, how fast rewards arrive, what…
- Should you build or buy the loyalty platform
Buy the loyalty platform, not build it, unless your programme's only defensible edge is a points or rewards mechanic no vendor can configure and you…
- Should you choose a headless loyalty platform or a suite
Choose a headless loyalty platform when your programme must live inside your own member experience and its earn, tier, and redemption rules will…
- Should you design controls for points laundering
Yes, design dedicated points laundering controls when your programme allows point transfers between accounts, sells points for cash, or offers…
- Should you design loyalty controls for employee fraud
Yes, when your programme has staff who can adjust balances, issue points, or process redemptions, design employee fraud controls before launch.
- Should you design loyalty for account takeover resistance
Yes, if your loyalty programme holds transferable points or points redeemable for cash equivalents.
- Should you fix the programme or relaunch it
Fix the programme first.
- Should you investigate incentive leakage
Investigate incentive leakage when redemption cost per point varies by channel or partner, or member service complaints point to missing value.
- Should you join a coalition or run a standalone programme
Run a standalone programme by default.
- Should you launch a co-brand card
No.
- Should you manage loyalty liability as a growth constraint
Yes.
- Should you model the cost of tier benefits before launch
Yes, model the cost of tier benefits before launch if you already hold earning and redemption data from a comparable programme or pilot.
- Should you modernise a legacy loyalty programme
Modernise a legacy loyalty programme only when the business can run a parallel accrual ledger for at least six months.
- Should you offer lifetime loyalty status
No, do not offer lifetime loyalty status as a broad member benefit.
- Should you offer points plus cash redemption
Yes.
- Should you rely on a breakage assumption
No.
- Should you report loyalty to the board as a growth channel or a liability
Report loyalty as a growth channel, not a liability.
- Should you reward sell in or sell through
Reward sell through.
- Should you round loyalty earnings up or down
Round up.
- Should you sell points to partners
Sell points to partners only when the wholesale price exceeds your expected redemption cost per point and the partnership reaches customers your own…
- Should you sell points to your issuer
Yes, sell points to your issuer as the primary funding line, but only with a hard price floor above your marginal redemption cost and a volume cap…
- Should you set a minimum redemption threshold
Do not set a minimum redemption threshold for digital rewards or account credits.
- Should you sunset a loyalty programme, and how should you end it
Yes, sunset a loyalty programme when it no longer changes member behaviour enough to pay for its own liability and operations.
- Should you use a taxonomy for loyalty fraud
Adopt a fraud taxonomy only when each category changes at least one control decision: block, review, clawback, or ignore.
- Should you use formal partner earn agreements
Use formal partner earn agreements for any partnership where members can earn points that create redemption liability.
- Should you use loyalty to incentivise technicians
Yes, but only when the loyalty points are tied to a quality metric the technician controls, such as first-time fix or completed preventive…
- Should you use spiffs or rebates for channel incentives
Use rebates as your default channel incentive and limit spiffs to short, product-specific pushes with airtight control.
- Should you validate claims before rewarding channel partners
Yes.
- Should your awards use dynamic or fixed pricing
Use fixed pricing for your core award chart.
- Should your loyalty membership be paid or free
Charge for membership only when the fee buys a recurring, calculable saving or entitlement that a free tier cannot deliver.
- Should your loyalty programme be proactive or reactionary
Be proactive where your data can fire a rule and reach the member before their next decision.
- Should your loyalty programme reward competing channels
No.
- Should your loyalty programme serve businesses or consumers
Serve consumers.
- Should your loyalty programme use points or cashback
Use points unless your programme sells undifferentiated products at thin margins where price comparison dominates.
- Should your points expire, and on what trigger
Yes.
- Should your programme build emotional or transactional loyalty
Build emotional loyalty unless your programme serves a low-involvement category where members switch for a one-cent price difference.
- What breaks in a loyalty migration
What breaks in a loyalty migration is the member's right to redeem at the old value.
- What should you do when points are stolen
Restore the member's stolen points immediately, freeze the compromised account, and require identity re-verification before re-enabling, within one…
- What should you do when the programme is cannibalising margin
Cut the earn rate to zero on any category where loyalty points push net margin below your floor.
- When does the card become the loyalty programme
The card becomes the loyalty programme when the card account is the rewards ledger: points are earned by card spend, held against the card, and…
- When is loyalty the wrong answer
Loyalty is the wrong answer when a business already receives repeat custom through necessity, contract, or structural convenience rather than customer…
- When should you cap earning
Cap earning when a member's points would otherwise cost more than the margin their spend produces after breakage.
- When should you devalue points and how do you survive it
Devalue points only when outstanding point liability genuinely threatens programme solvency, and do it by changing future earning rates rather than…
- When should you run a status match
Run a status match only when you can identify a competitor tier whose members would need to shift enough spend to your programme to re-qualify on your…
- When to expire points
Expire points after 24 consecutive months without earning or redemption activity.
- Where must LLMs not be used in loyalty
Never let an LLM decide, alter, or explain a member's points balance, accrual, expiry, redemption value, or tier status.
- Who should own loyalty
Own loyalty as a single commercial function reporting to the chief executive, with one person accountable for both earning rates and redemption…