Decisions · Partners and channel

Should you launch a co-brand card

No. Do not launch a co-brand card unless your programme already has a large, transactionally active member base and a bank partner that will pay you enough per account to cover the additional points liability you create. For most loyalty programmes, the margin and attention cost of a card are not justified.

The decision

This is a decision about whether to attach a payment instrument to your loyalty currency. A co-brand card turns everyday spend into points at scale, but it also converts your programme from a marketing asset into a financial product with issuer dependencies, credit risk controls and new member expectations. The underlying mechanism is a triangle: the bank finances credit and absorbs credit losses, you issue points that create a future redemption liability, and the member decides whether the earning rate is worth taking the card. The decision is not whether cards are attractive in general. It is whether your programme has enough member density and negotiating power to make the bank pay for the liability it forces you to carry.

What it costs you

Not launching a co-brand card costs you the forgone interchange share and the incremental member engagement that a successful card can create. For an illustrative programme with 30,000 members who would have carried the card, assume the bank pays you 0.5 cents for each point issued and each active card drives 250 dollars of monthly spend at one point per dollar. That produces 90,000,000 points per year, or 450,000 dollars of card-linked revenue you would forgo. The same card would create 810,000 dollars of new redemption liability at a fully loaded cost of 0.9 cents per point. The net effect of not launching is a saving of 360,000 dollars, because the avoided liability exceeds the lost revenue. The real cost you bear is the opportunity cost of a daily card touchpoint and the purchase data you would have gained, but that opportunity cost is usually smaller than the structural cost of issuing the points.

How to decide

Apply three tests. First, count how many of your members make at least 12 transactions with your brand or partners each month. If fewer than 20,000 members clear that bar, a card will not generate enough usage to justify the issuer's fixed costs. Second, ask a bank what it will pay you per account and per point, not just per approval. If the total annual payment per active card is less than the fully loaded cost of points you expect to issue, the card will transfer margin away from your programme. Third, check whether your redemption liability already fluctuates by more than 15 per cent month to month. If it does, adding card-driven point accrual will make your breakage forecasting harder, not easier. If you fail any of these, do not launch.

What would change our mind

We would change our position if you can negotiate a bank deal where the issuer, not your programme, bears the redemption liability for points earned on the card. That could happen if the bank buys points from you at a fixed price per point that exceeds your fully loaded redemption cost, or if the card operates on bank-owned points that convert to your currency only at redemption and at a rate you set. In that structure, the card adds member value without increasing your deferred revenue. A second condition is regulatory or competitive pressure that makes a co-brand card the only way to retain your most active members. If both conditions appear, launching becomes the lower-risk choice.

Related