Positions
Positions
Where this site takes a side, states who disagrees, and says what would change its mind.
18 published
- B2B incentives are a decade behind consumer loyalty
B2B incentives are a decade behind consumer loyalty.
- Breakage is not profit
Breakage is not profit.
- Coalition loyalty keeps failing for structural reasons
Coalition loyalty programmes cannot sustain recognition because no single partner owns the customer relationship.
- Emotional loyalty is real but badly measured
Emotional loyalty is real, but the industry measures it badly.
- Gamification is mostly decoration
Gamification in loyalty programmes is mostly decoration: badges, points, streaks and leaderboards rarely change whether a customer returns.
- LLMs do not belong in the points ledger
LLMs do not belong in the points ledger because the ledger must be deterministic and auditable, and a language model's output is neither.
- Loyalty fraud is underreported because disclosing it is embarrassing
Loyalty fraud is underreported because disclosing it is embarrassing.
- Most loyalty programmes are discount programmes
Most loyalty programmes are discount programmes.
- Most programmes should have fewer tiers
Most loyalty programmes should run fewer tiers.
- Owning your loyalty data matters more than your platform choice
Owning your loyalty data matters more than your platform choice.
- Paid loyalty is eating free loyalty
Paid loyalty is eating free loyalty.
- Personalisation has a ceiling
Personalisation has a ceiling because the reward mechanics that would carry it run aground on sector economics.
- Points expiry is usually a liability decision not an engagement one
Points expiry is usually a liability decision, not an engagement one.
- Programme terms should be readable
Programme terms should be readable.
- The best loyalty metric is incrementality and almost nobody measures it
The only loyalty metric that separates a programme's effect from what members would have done anyway is incrementality, and almost no programme…
- The devaluation treadmill is a trust problem
A loyalty programme that repeatedly cuts earn and redeem value is not repricing.
- Tier inflation is the default failure mode
Tier inflation is the default failure mode.
- Transferability is underrated
Loyalty currencies and status should be transferable by default.