Decisions · Partners and channel

How should you allocate market development funds in loyalty

Put at least 80 per cent of market development funds into member-facing earn accelerators and redemption discounts that expire within one billing cycle. Hold back no more than 20 per cent for acquisition advertising. The condition is that the programme has a funded points liability and can track incremental redemption by campaign.

The decision

Market development funds are partner money governed by a choice: purchase attention or purchase redemption. Attention spending buys media placements that may or may not produce enrolled members. Redemption spending buys a temporary reduction in the cost of using points, which acts directly on the programme's core economic loop. Because loyalty revenue is recognised when points are redeemed, not when they are issued, a fund that shortens the time to redemption improves both partner billings and liability accuracy. The decision is not a media allocation question; it is a balance sheet question about where the partner subsidy lands.

What it costs you

The main cost is margin compression on redemptions that would have happened without the bonus. You also forgo acquisition media that might have enrolled new actives, and you consume engineering capacity to build expiry rules, segment lists and reconciliation. Member trust is at risk if a bonus is advertised but not honoured due to a technical cap, so the cap and expiry must be visible before redemption. From a liability view, a short-dated bonus is safer than a permanent earn rate increase, because unused bonus expires and never becomes a balance-sheet liability.

For illustration, take a fund of 100,000 dollars used as a 20 per cent bonus on redemptions up to 200 dollars per member. Suppose 2,000 members use the full 200 dollars. The bonus cost is 2,000 times 200 times 20 per cent, or 80,000 dollars. The value redeemed totals 400,000 dollars. If the programme had expected 70 per cent of that to be redeemed anyway, the incremental redemption is 400,000 minus 280,000, or 120,000 dollars. At an 8 per cent partner commission, the incremental revenue is 9,600 dollars. The net cost before engineering time is 80,000 minus 9,600, or 70,400 dollars. That 70,400 dollars is the subsidy given up to move redemptions earlier, before any engineering time is added.

How to decide

To decide, run a 90 day test with two cells. Cell A continues your current acquisition media mix with 100 per cent of MDF. Cell B moves 80 per cent of MDF into a 15 per cent redemption bonus capped at 50 dollars per member and expiring in 30 days, leaving 20 per cent for acquisition. Measure incremental redemption value and partner commission per dollar of MDF in each cell. After 90 days, compare the cost per dollar of incremental redemption in Cell B with the cost per enrolled active member in Cell A. If Cell B produces at least one dollar of incremental redeemed value for every 1.25 dollars of MDF spent, keep the split. If not, reverse it.

What would change our mind

The recommendation flips if your programme has a breakage rate below 5 per cent and a partner commission below 3 per cent. In that case, nearly all redemptions would have happened without a bonus, and the partner fee cannot offset the discount. The funds are then better spent on acquisition media to enlarge the active base. A second flip condition is if you cannot track incremental redemption by campaign, because then you cannot verify the core mechanism and should not spend MDF on it.

Related