Decisions · Strategy and governance

Who should own loyalty

Own loyalty as a single commercial function reporting to the chief executive, with one person accountable for both earning rates and redemption liability. Marketing may run member communications, but it must not control the economics. The condition is that this owner can veto any promotion that increases future cost by more than its incremental margin.

The decision

The decision is not which department runs the loyalty portal. It is whether the initiative is treated as a marketing channel or as a balance-sheet commitment. The mechanism is future cost: every point issued creates a redemption expense, and every redemption changes margin in the period it occurs. Ownership must sit where that future cost can be traded off against revenue, not where enrolment or click metrics dominate.

A scheme owned by marketing optimises for sign-ups and active members. A scheme owned by finance minimises redemption spending. A scheme owned by product designs for frequency of purchase. None of these alone holds the full trade. The correct owner must be able to cut an earning rate, postpone a promotion, or block a redemption offer without losing the member relationship. That role should report to the chief executive and hold a single commercial budget.

What it costs you

When ownership is split, the cost appears as margin leakage and future obligation shocks. Take an illustrative 100,000 dollars of member spend. At one point per dollar and a funding cost of 0.8 cents per point, the future obligation is 100,000 points times 0.008 dollars, or 800 dollars. If the team running campaigns doubles the earning rate to two points per dollar without finance approval, the same spend creates 200,000 points and 1,600 dollars in future redemptions. That is an extra 800 dollars, or 0.8 percentage points of the 100,000 dollars spend.

The real damage is not that one arithmetic. It is that repeated changes of this kind go unnoticed until the redemption ledger swells. Finance then tightens rules, members see devaluations, and trust falls. Engineering time gets spent adjusting point engines and expiry logic instead of improving the member experience. Operating capacity goes to reconciling exceptions across departments. The owner who could have made the trade-off in one meeting was not in the room.

How to decide

Apply this test to your own scheme. For the next loyalty change on your roadmap, identify the person who can approve both the earning rate and the redemption budget in the same meeting. If that approval requires two sign-offs from leaders with different incentives, your scheme has no owner. Ask a simpler question: who can say no to a promotion that increases future redemptions by more than the incremental margin from the sales it drives? If the answer is nobody below the chief executive, ownership is missing.

If the honest answer is that one team controls earning, another controls future obligation, and a third controls redemption mechanics, you are running a committee with three vetoes. That is not ownership of the member proposition. Consolidate the commercial authority into one role, even if operational teams remain separate. Ownership is a decision right, not a department name.

What would change our mind

We would reverse this recommendation if the loyalty currency carries no financial redemption cost because all rewards are supplied by partners and the issuer retains no obligation. In that narrow case the scheme is a media property, and marketing ownership is right. We would also reverse it if the outstanding obligation is so small that it never exceeds the cost of one month of the owner's time; then the overhead of a dedicated role is not justified. But for any scheme where the company must fund points or holds a contractual promise to members, split ownership is the expensive default.

Related