Decisions · Earn and redemption

Should your awards use dynamic or fixed pricing

Use fixed pricing for your core award chart. Dynamic pricing should be reserved for redemptions where the cash cost is genuinely variable and members already expect a floating rate. Fixed pricing protects the promise of points, while dynamic pricing quietly converts points into a discount coupon.

The decision

Choosing between fixed and dynamic pricing is not a choice about technology. It is a choice about who carries the yield risk between the date points are sold and the date they are redeemed. With fixed pricing, the programme guarantees a point price for an award and absorbs any change in the cash fare. With dynamic pricing, the member absorbs that change, because the point price tracks the cash price. The mechanism underneath is simple: fixed pricing creates a stable liability, dynamic pricing creates a variable discount. A loyalty programme that promises a reward for repeat behaviour needs a stable liability. A booking tool that monetises idle demand can use a variable discount. Decide which institution you are running before you touch the award chart.

What it costs you

The recommended path, fixed pricing, costs you liability when cash fares rise. You sell points at a known rate, you promise award seats at a known point price, and you keep the difference. When the cash fare moves above your break-even fare, the difference becomes negative. Illustrative calculation: you sell 60,000 points at 2 cents per point, receiving 1,200 dollars. You publish a fixed award at 60,000 points for a route that normally sells for 900 dollars, giving the member 1.5 cents per point. If the cash fare rises to 1,500 dollars, the member still redeems at 60,000 points, receiving 2.5 cents per point. You collected 1,200 dollars for points that now must buy a 1,500 dollar seat, a 300 dollar loss per redemption. If 200 members redeem after that fare rise, the total loss is 60,000 dollars (200 times 300). That is not a pricing error; it is the price of honouring a fixed promise.

Fixed pricing also costs engineering time. A fixed chart needs a published table, a partner mapping, a seasonal blackout policy, and a process for exceptions. Every time a partner changes its own fare structure, your chart team must re-test the redemption logic. Those hours are real operating capacity that dynamic pricing can avoid. But do not confuse avoiding that work with saving money. The work exists either way: under dynamic pricing, it moves to the member's side, where each member computes whether the points are worth using.

How to decide

Apply this test to your own programme. First, name the cash fare at which your most widely used fixed award breaks even. If you cannot name it, you are not ready for any pricing model. Second, check whether your members treat points as savings for an aspirational trip or as a discount on the fare they would otherwise buy. If they treat points as savings, fixed pricing is the only model that keeps that behaviour. Third, ask your finance team whether the point liability is a debt due to members or a marketing expense that can be repriced. If it is a debt, fixed pricing is mandatory. If all three checks point to fixed pricing, publish the chart and defend it. If any check points the other way, fix the underlying gap before changing the award model, because switching to dynamic pricing will not turn a broken loyalty contract into a healthy one.

What would change our mind

We would change this recommendation if your fixed point liability exceeds 24 months of your loyalty operating margin and you cannot reduce redemption capacity or raise point sale prices without breaching existing member terms. Under that condition, fixed pricing stops being a loyalty promise and becomes a solvency problem. Dynamic pricing is then the lesser harm, because it shares the yield risk with members before the programme repudiates its own chart. The switch should be announced as a default, not a punishment, and limited to award types where the cash cost is genuinely volatile. Short of that condition, the fixed chart is the only structure that keeps the loyalty in the programme.

Related