Decisions · Partners and channel
How should you choose a loyalty issuing partner
Choose a loyalty issuing partner by assigning unredeemed point liability and member data control to the party best able to manage them. Accept a lower upfront payment when the issuer takes full breakage risk and gives you transaction level member data, rather than the highest per point bid.
The decision
This is not a choice between card networks or reward currencies. It is a choice about which organisation carries the obligation to redeem points that members may never use, and which organisation holds the transaction data needed to forecast that obligation. An issuing partner pays for the points it creates, but the programme retains an accounting liability for every unredeemed point unless that liability is transferred. The mechanism underneath is risk assignment: each point issued today is a future claim on a reward, and the partner who accepts breakage risk gets a lower per point price as compensation.
What it costs you
The recommended path costs you gross revenue and engineering time. A partner that takes breakage liability and gives data will pay less per point than a partner that leaves the liability with you. For example, suppose a programme issues 100 million points per month. A high bidder pays 1.0 cents per point and the programme keeps liability. The recommended partner pays 0.7 cents per point and takes liability. The gross difference is 300,000 dollars per month, because 100 million points at 0.3 cents less is 300,000 dollars. Assume breakage is 25 per cent, so the programme with the high bidder expects to redeem 75 million points. At a redemption cost of 0.8 cents per point, that liability is 600,000 dollars, which is 75 million times 0.8 cents. Net after redemption cost under the high bidder is 400,000 dollars, while net under the recommended partner is 700,000 dollars. This is illustrative. The real cost is not the lower fee but the capacity you need to integrate raw transaction data and the loss of upside if your breakage turns out higher than the partner assumed.
How to decide
Apply this test before signing any term sheet. Ask the shortlisted partner to produce a cohort level redemption forecast in writing and to state the present value of unredeemed point liability under three scenarios: your base case, a ten per cent lower redemption rate, and a ten per cent higher redemption rate. If the partner will not put that liability on its own balance sheet, do not give them issuing rights. If they will, and they also agree to deliver daily transaction feeds with member level identifiers that your finance team can audit, choose them over any partner offering a higher per point payment without liability transfer. The test is not the card's annual percentage rate or its sign-up bonus. The test is whether you can price the points they issue after they leave the room.
What would change our mind
We would reverse this recommendation for a programme that manages breakage as a core competency. If a programme can show two years of cohort level redemption timing data within two percentage points of its forecast and maintains a dedicated liability reserve equal to one hundred and twenty per cent of expected future redemptions, then the higher upfront payment plus retained breakage becomes worth more than the liability transfer. In that case, choose the highest per point bidder and keep the data yourself. This is not a hedge; it is a test of whether the programme already does the work the partner would otherwise charge for.