Decisions · Economics and liability
When should you devalue points and how do you survive it
Devalue points only when outstanding point liability genuinely threatens programme solvency, and do it by changing future earning rates rather than rewriting balances already issued while the programme continues. Survive by announcing the cause, keeping existing balances whole where possible and giving clear notice before new rates apply.
The decision
This is a decision about the unit of value inside a loyalty programme and the mechanism of redemption cost. Every point is a promise that carries a cash-equivalent liability, and a devaluation either asks more points for the same reward or gives less reward for the same points. The real choice is not whether members will dislike the change; it is whether you can keep the promise at its current price without exhausting the margin that funds redemptions. The recommendation is to alter only the earning of future points while the programme continues, never the value of balances already issued.
What it costs you
The recommended path keeps existing balances whole, so you forgo the immediate accounting benefit of a retroactive write-down. As an illustration, take a programme with 800 million points outstanding and a cheapest popular reward of 10,000 points for a voucher worth 100 dollars. That prices a point at one cent, so the liability is 8,000,000 dollars. If you instead charge 12,500 points for the same voucher worth 100 dollars, a point falls to 0.8 cents and the liability becomes 6,400,000 dollars. The difference is 1,600,000 dollars. That 1,600,000 dollars is what a retroactive devaluation would remove from your books and what a future-only change leaves in place. You must fund it from current margin or cash. On top of that, you spend engineering time reworking earning tables, redemption catalogues and terms pages, often two to four months of one team, while call centre volume rises as members ask what their points are now worth.
How to decide
Work out the true liability per point from the redemption option your most engaged members actually use, not from the catalogue item nobody takes. Multiply that per-point value by total points outstanding and write down the result. Next, estimate the gross margin you expect from those same members over the next twelve months after the costs of fulfilling their future reward redemptions. If the outstanding liability is more than twice that twelve-month margin and you have no covenant or reserve that covers it, devalue future earning now and announce it before the next statement cycle. If the liability is lower, do not devalue; fix the redemption mix or reduce future earn rates where the contract allows.
What would change our mind
We would change our mind about future-only devaluation if the programme is being wound down and there is no future earning left to adjust. In a wind-down, existing balances become the remaining liability, and a negotiated, transparent reduction to those balances is less damaging than allowing redemptions to fail. Outside that condition, touching existing balances is the one move that converts a pricing problem into a permanent member exodus.