Decisions · Economics and liability

How to set a point value

Set a point at one cent of redemption value, fixed and published, and set the earn rate from the margin you can fund. Do not copy a competitor's point value or let it drift. If one cent cannot be funded, issue fewer points, not a weaker point. The exception is a market where competitors already honour more than one cent and you can fund that liability.

The decision

The decision is not how many points a purchase earns. That is a separate earn rate. The decision is what a single point is worth when it leaves the member's account. We recommend fixing that worth at one cent of redemption value, published and honoured without exception, unless your competitive set already honours more and you can fund the higher liability. The mechanism is unit of account: a fixed point value turns every catalogue item into a simple division problem for the member and a known future cash outflow for you. Floating values hide margin decisions inside the catalogue and force members to do arithmetic across every redemption.

What it costs you

The following example is illustrative. A programme that issues 900,000 points in a month at one cent per point adds 9,000 dollars to its deferred liability. If those points were earned at one point per dollar, the liability is exactly 1% of the 900,000 dollars of revenue that created them. When redemptions happen, the cash cost depends on what you pay for rewards. Say a 25,000 point reward has a shelf price of 250 dollars, so the member's value is one cent per point. If you buy that reward from a supplier at 212.50 dollars, your cash cost is 0.85 cents per point. On 900,000 points redeemed, you pay 7,650 dollars, leaving 1,350 dollars of liability that may never be called. That 1,350 dollars is not savings you can spend; it is a buffer against higher redemption rates. The real cost of the one cent decision is the margin you give up on every future point, plus the engineering time to hard-code the value in redemption logic and to refuse requests for exceptions.

How to decide

Take the five cheapest rewards that a new member can actually redeem today. For each one, divide the shelf price by the number of points required. If the result is not one cent, you have not set a point value; you have set a range. A second check is to model a twelve month period in which members redeem every point they earn. If the resulting cash outflow would force you to cut the earn rate, cut the earn rate now and leave the point value untouched. These two tests expose whether the point value is an operational commitment or a promotional claim.

What would change our mind

We would change the one cent recommendation if the published competitor standard in your market is two cents per point, your margin before loyalty is above 5%, and you can fund the extra liability without reducing the earn rate below one point per dollar. In that case, a one cent point is a visible handicap, and the acquisition cost of explaining the difference will exceed the extra redemption cost. Then set the point at two cents, publish it, and keep the earn rate unchanged only if the numbers above hold. We would also change the recommendation if you own the reward inventory and its marginal cost is below one cent per point, because a fixed one cent point would create a redemption profit that invites member complaints. In that case, set the point at the marginal cost floor, even if it is a fraction of a cent.

Related