Decisions · Earn and redemption

When to expire points

Expire points after 24 consecutive months without earning or redemption activity. Keep the balance alive indefinitely for any member who earns or redeems even one point in that window, and send a written notice 60 days before forfeiture. members inactive for a year or more exceed roughly a fifth of your liability, set the window to at least twice your median purchase interval, give 90 days of notice, and never apply the rule retroactively without a full notice cycle.

The decision

The question is not whether to expire points but which trigger releases the liability. Points are a promise to deliver future value; expiry is the moment the programme stops carrying that promise. A calendar age rule, such as all points lapse three years after issue, punishes active members and creates customer service noise. An inactivity rule ties expiry to the last time the member earned or redeemed, because that is the only observable signal of whether the member still values the balance. The mechanism is a clock that resets to zero on any earning or redemption event; after 24 consecutive months without either event, the balance is written off. This turns an accounting estimate into a behaviour-based rule and keeps the promise alive for anyone still using the programme.

What it costs you

The cost is deferred breakage income and engineering time. The rule only releases liability after a member has been silent for 24 months, so any member who makes a single earn or redemption at month 23 keeps the full balance alive for another two years. Take an illustrative programme with 20,000,000 dollars in outstanding point liability at one cent per point, which is 2,000,000,000 points. If 6 percent of that liability belongs to members who earn or redeem one point every 23 months just to reset the clock, that is 1,200,000 dollars, or 120,000,000 points, that never expire under this rule. A three-year calendar expiry would let the programme release that amount, but it would also confiscate points from members who were active at other times. The engineering cost is modest: the system must store a last activity timestamp, run a daily batch to identify accounts silent for 24 months, and send a notice 60 days before forfeiture. Member trust is the offsetting asset; a hard calendar expiry can trigger complaints and chargebacks far beyond the saved liability.

How to decide

For each member, ask whether you can state with certainty the date of the last earn or redemption. If you cannot, do not expire points until you can. If you can, set the expiry clock at 24 months from that date and require any earn or redemption to reset it to zero. Then check your breakage forecast: if carrying balances beyond 24 months for occasional users raises liability above your finance team's tolerance by more than the cost of writing and sending one notice per affected member, shorten the window for members with no activity of any kind to 18 months, but never below 12 months. A programme that cannot send a notice 60 days before expiry should not expire points at all.

What would change our mind

We would reverse this recommendation if the regulator in your main market treats points as prepaid value with no expiry or requires escheatment after a set period. In that case, the right path is no expiry and transfer of dormant balances to the state. The recommendation also flips if you cannot send individual written notice 60 days before forfeiture; without notice, forfeiture is taking value without consent, and no breakage gain justifies the trust damage.

Related