Decisions · Earn and redemption
How should you price a loyalty redemption catalogue
Price each redemption at the programme's marginal cost plus a fixed uplift that covers liability and breakage, not at the retail price or a competitive 'market rate'. The main condition is that you have clean unit economics for each reward and a liability policy that treats unredeemed points as a balance sheet item.
The decision
The decision is what value a point should carry when a member spends it, because a redemption catalogue is the point's only claim on real money. The mechanism is deferred liability: every point issued is a promise to deliver something later. Setting the catalogue price fixes the cost of settling that promise. If you price at retail, you are telling the finance team that a point's liability is the shelf price of the reward, which overstates what you will actually pay when a member redeems. If you price at your marginal cost plus a fixed uplift, you make the catalogue reflect the cash you will spend, not a number borrowed from a shop window.
What it costs you
The recommended path costs you margin per point today, because every point now redeems into more reward value than retail pricing would allow. The cost is not a one time fee; it is a permanent increase in your points liability. An illustrative calculation shows the size. Take a reward item that costs you 80 dollars to procure and has a retail price of 120 dollars. Under retail pricing, you require 12,000 points for the item, so each point carries an expected cost of 80 dollars divided by 12,000 points, which is 0.00667 dollars per point. Under cost-plus pricing with a 15 percent uplift, you set the price at 92 dollars and require 9,200 points, so each point carries 80 dollars divided by 9,200 points, which is 0.00870 dollars per point. The difference is 0.00203 dollars per point. If your programme has 100 million points outstanding, that difference increases the balance sheet liability from 667,000 dollars to 870,000 dollars, a jump of 203,000 dollars. You also spend more on fulfilment per redemption because members can reach rewards sooner, which may push your operating capacity if redemptions spike.
How to decide
Apply this test to your own programme. Take your ten highest volume rewards and compute the full marginal cost of each: procurement, shipping, packaging, customer service time, payment processing, and any partner commission. Add a fixed uplift that covers your cost of capital and your breakage estimate, but keep the uplift below 20 percent or you are just retailing. Then set the points required by dividing that cost-plus figure by the earning rate of a typical active member over six months. If the resulting points required for a reward is equal to or less than what that member can earn in six months of normal behaviour, adopt the cost-plus price. If the points required exceeds six months of earning, you are not pricing a redemption catalogue; you are running a points bank that no one can withdraw from.
What would change our mind
We would flip to retail pricing if your points are sold to corporate partners for cash in advance and your redemption catalogue is a standalone profit centre with no deferred liability on your own balance sheet. In that model, the catalogue's job is to maximise gross margin per redemption because the cost of points has already been recovered from partners, and any unredeemed points are not your liability. Under that condition, pricing at retail is not a mistake; it is the correct transfer price between the partner funded points pool and the rewards business. For any programme that still carries the liability itself, cost-plus remains the honest price.