Decisions · Strategy and governance

Should you fix the programme or relaunch it

Fix the programme first. Relaunch only when the core earn and burn promise has collapsed, regulation forces a reset, or the brand is so damaged that a clean name can recover more members than the fix can retain.

The decision

Deciding whether to fix a loyalty programme or relaunch it is a decision about which contract you are willing to break. Fixing changes the rules inside the existing relationship: earn rates, redemption windows, exclusions, partner range, communication. Relaunching closes that relationship and starts a new one under a new name or reset balance. The mechanism underneath is not technology; it is liability continuity. A fix keeps the accrued points as a promise you must honour. A relaunch lets you write off some of that promise, but only by telling members their past behaviour no longer counts in the same way.

What it costs you

Fixing the programme costs you the full remaining liability and the engineering time to correct the rules. You do not get to escape points already issued. That is the honest price of continuity. Here is an illustrative calculation. Suppose a member holds 8,000 points worth one cent each. That is a liability of 80 dollars per member. If you fix the programme, you keep that 80 dollars on the books and spend additional engineering hours on rule changes. If you relaunch and convert legacy points at 0.25 cents, liability falls to 20 dollars per member, a write-down of 60 dollars. But that write-down is not free. If the relaunch causes one lost purchase of 200 dollars at a 30 percent margin, the lost margin is 60 dollars, exactly equal to the liability saving. The programme then has the same cost but a smaller and less trusting active base.

How to decide

Apply a two part test to your own programme. First, write down the three most common member complaints from support and redemption data. If at least two can be fixed by changing mechanics without cutting the earn rate, the programme is fixable. Second, ask whether an active member with 10,000 points would recognise the programme after your proposed changes. If the name, basic earn rate and redemption promise remain recognisable, fix. If you cannot keep the basic promise or the name itself is a liability, the test points to relaunch. Do not relaunch merely because the technology is old or the liability is large; those are fixable problems with a clear budget.

What would change our mind

We would flip the recommendation to relaunch if the earn rate cannot produce enough margin to fund the promised liability without regulatory breach, or if the brand has become so damaged that member re-enrolment under a new name would exceed retention from fixing. In that condition, the write-off is no longer an accounting dodge but the cheapest way to end an unkeepable promise. The relaunch must then carry a narrower promise than the old programme, not a new loyalty scheme with the same economics and a fresh coat of paint.

Related