Decisions · Earn and redemption

Should you set a minimum redemption threshold

Do not set a minimum redemption threshold for digital rewards or account credits. Let members redeem any positive balance as soon as it covers the smallest real option; the only defensible threshold is a per-item floor for physical rewards where external fulfilment cost genuinely exceeds the points redeemed.

The decision

The decision is whether the programme will refuse to honour points below a set balance, turning active earners into locked-out holders. Underneath that is a choice about who carries the cost of small redemptions. A minimum threshold does not reduce the liability for those points; it postpones recognition and pushes members to earn more before they can use what they already have. Points behave like a currency only if the smallest positive balance can buy something. When a programme says 1,499 points are worth nothing but 1,500 are worth a voucher, the point is not a unit of stored value. It is an obligation gated by an arbitrary rule.

What it costs you

The recommended path removes a lever that some programmes use to defer breakage, but keeping the threshold costs more in member trust and support load than it saves in fulfilment. Say it is illustrative. A member sits on 700 points under a 1,000 point minimum. At an earning rate of 1 point per dollar spent and a redemption value of 0.5 cents per point, those 700 points are worth 3 dollars and 50 cents, but the member must spend another 300 dollars to earn the missing 300 points before redeeming anything. That is 300 dollars of additional spend required to unlock 3 dollars and 50 cents of value. If the member contacts support to ask why redemption is blocked, and one support interaction costs the programme 8 dollars in staff time, the programme has spent 8 dollars to avoid releasing 3 dollars and 50 cents. That is a net cash cost of 4 dollars and 50 cents, before considering the goodwill lost when the member realises the rule exists. The 3 dollars and 50 cents does not disappear; it remains a deferred liability on the books.

How to decide

Test each reward category separately. First ask whether a member with the lowest positive balance can complete a redemption online without staff involvement. If yes, remove any threshold for that category. If no, identify the smallest external fulfilment cost per redemption event. For digital vouchers and account credits, external fulfilment costs are the face value of the item plus any payment processing fee charged per transaction. A threshold above the smallest available voucher value is therefore a programme choice, not a cost offset. For physical goods, add the pack, post and payment processing cost and set the threshold no higher than the points value that covers those costs. If a single point cannot be redeemed because the smallest reward starts at 500 points, the programme has decided that 499 points have no value. That choice should be visible in the member terms, not hidden as a redemption rule.

What would change our mind

We would change our recommendation if a programme can demonstrate that every redemption below a proposed threshold costs more in external fulfilment fees than the points are worth, and no account credit or digital voucher can be issued without incurring that same fee. That is a real condition: a fixed cost charged by a third party for each redemption event, not an internal accounting preference. Under that condition, a threshold set at the point value covering the external fee is honest. Without it, the threshold is a breakage lever dressed as a member rule.

Related