Decisions · Earn and redemption

How should you set loyalty earn rates

Set the base earn rate at one point per dollar of revenue, then cut category rates where gross margin is below 20 percent and raise them only with tested proof of incremental spend. This keeps the liability funded by the transaction that creates it.

The decision

The decision is not about generous versus stingy points. It is about which transactions fund the future redemption promise. An earn rate is a unit price for a deferred discount, and the mechanism is accrual: each issued point should be recognised as a cost against the sale that created it. If the sale cannot carry that cost, the rate is wrong even if members like it.

What it costs you

The recommended path costs you a known liability and margin reduction on every sale, not ongoing engineering effort. An illustrative calculation for a programme with 2 million dollars of monthly sales and a 20 percent gross margin shows the exact trade-off. At one point per dollar, monthly issuance is 2 million points. With a redemption value of one cent per point and a redemption rate of 80 percent, monthly liability cost is 2,000,000 points times 0.8 times 0.01 dollars, which equals 16,000 dollars. Monthly gross profit is 2,000,000 dollars times 0.20, which equals 400,000 dollars. The base rate consumes 4 percent of gross profit. If the same programme raised the base rate to two points per dollar, monthly liability cost would be 32,000 dollars, consuming 8 percent of gross profit, while gross profit remains 400,000 dollars. The member trust cost appears only if you later cut the headline rate, which the margin-based adjustments avoid. Operating capacity is tested when accumulated points are redeemed, but the one point default keeps that peak obligation within one percent of monthly sales.

How to decide

Apply this test. Sort last twelve months of transactions by category and gross margin. For categories with gross margin at 20 percent or above, set one point per dollar. For margin from 10 to 19 percent, set half a point per dollar. For margin below 10 percent, set zero points or award only on spend above cost. Then calculate the projected redemption cost per 100 dollars of sales: at one point per dollar, one cent redemption value and 80 percent redemption, that is 80 cents per 100 dollars. If average gross margin is under 20 percent, use the category rates instead of a single headline rate. If you cannot measure margin by category, do not run a points programme at all.

What would change our mind

We would raise the base rate only when a controlled test shows that each additional point issued returns more incremental gross margin than its liability cost within six months. The recommendation flips to zero base earn rate if an organisation's average gross margin is below 10 percent, because a one point per dollar default at one cent redemption consumes more than 10 percent of gross profit before any breakage adjustment. Conversely, if transaction-level data proves that specific member groups cover a two point rate with extra margin, that becomes the correct rate for those groups, not for everyone.

Related