Decisions · Tiers and status
Should a tier change use a soft landing or hard reset
Use a soft landing for any tier change that reduces value or raises thresholds, provided the tier continues to exist and the old status was earned in good faith. Keep members at their current tier for one further cycle or drop them one level, never to zero.
The decision
A tier change is not a reissue of benefits; it is a repricing of status that members have already bought with spend. The choice is between amortising that status over a transition period or voiding it immediately. Soft landing is the amortisation route. The mechanism is that status is a form of stored value: the programme issued it against past behaviour, and changing the table after the fact confiscates that value unless a transition rule is applied. The actual decision is therefore how long the old promise remains honoured, not whether the new thresholds are fair.
What it costs you
The recommended path costs you the difference between the benefits a soft landed member receives and the benefits they would receive after a hard reset, for the length of the transition. This is real liability, not goodwill. It shows up as lounge access, upgrade priority, bonus points, and service capacity that must be funded while the member may not be generating enough new margin to cover it.
Assume a programme soft lands 15,000 top tier members at second tier for 12 months. Suppose second tier costs 7.50 dollars per member per month more than base in variable benefits. The extra cost is 15,000 times 7.50 times 12, or 1,350,000 dollars. Now assume that without the soft landing 40 per cent of those members would stop placing new business with the programme, losing 900 dollars of annual margin each. That lost margin is 15,000 times 0.40 times 900, or 5,400,000 dollars. The soft landing therefore spends 1,350,000 dollars to protect 5,400,000 dollars of contribution. This is illustrative, not a forecast; replace the quantities with your own unit economics.
How to decide
Apply this test to each member, not to the whole base. A soft landing is correct for any member who has at least 80 per cent of the new qualification requirement already met in the trailing 12 months. For those members, the old status is close enough to the new standard that one further cycle costs little and preserves a relationship that remains commercially active. For members below 80 per cent, do not soft land; hard reset them to the new earned tier. Then run a second pass: if a top tier member below 80 per cent has been in that tier for less than six months, give a one tier drop rather than zero, because the old promise is recent enough that fairness still binds. This two stage rule limits liability to the members most likely to requalify, and limits resentment to the members least likely to remain profitable.
What would change our mind
A hard reset becomes the right answer when the programme removes the tier entirely or changes the benefit set so completely that a soft landing has no corresponding tier to rest in. If the old top tier maps to nothing in the new structure, then letting members keep it for a cycle is not a landing; it is a suspended cancellation. The recommendation also flips when the old status was earned under terms that the programme can no longer legally honour, for example a regulatory change that prohibits the benefit. In that case, a hard reset with clear notice is less destructive than a soft landing that must be clawed back later.