Decisions · Earn and redemption

Should you allow point transfers

Do not allow open member-to-member point transfers. Permit them only inside a verified household account or on proof of death, capped at 50,000 points per member per calendar year. Without that restriction, transfers create a parallel currency that arbitrageurs and fraudsters will use against your redemption margin.

The decision

The decision is whether to build a feature that lets one member move points out of their account and into another member's account. The mechanism underneath is a balance sheet transfer: the points do not disappear, they are not earned again, and they do not create new revenue. They simply change who can redeem them. That means you keep the same liability but lose control over when and how it is settled, and you give a resale value to points you never priced for resale.

What it costs you

The real cost is not the transfer itself, it is the change in redemption behaviour and the support load. Transferred points concentrate in accounts that redeem immediately, so your liability stops being a low-interest float and becomes a demand deposit. You also create a grey market: members with expiring or unwanted points sell them below your redemption value, and the buyer redeems at full value, eating the margin you would have kept from an expired balance or a direct sale.

Illustrative calculation. Suppose your programme has 10 million points outstanding, each worth one cent at redemption, so total liability is 100,000 dollars. If you allow transfers and 1 percent of points, 100,000 points, move each month from inactive members to active redeemers, those points are redeemed immediately instead of expiring or sitting dormant. Your liability drops by 1,000 dollars that month either way, but the margin is lower because the receiving member used points you could have sold as a top-up at 2 cents per point. Lost margin on those 100,000 points is 100,000 points times 0.01 dollars of margin, or 1,000 dollars. Add support cost: 30 transfer disputes per month at 25 dollars per hour for 30 minutes each is 375 dollars. In one month that is 1,375 dollars of avoidable cost on a 100,000 dollar liability.

How to decide

Apply this test. First, find whether your terms and conditions already forbid transfers. If they do, enforce them before building anything. Second, ask if any two members in your programme can already pool points through a shared account or family plan. If the answer is yes, you are already allowing transfers informally, and you need a formal cap, not an open feature. Third, check your fraud and support capacity: can you absorb 30 extra disputes per month and a 0.5 percent increase in redemption velocity without changing your breakage assumptions? If not, do not allow transfers. If you can absorb both, allow only a household transfer capped at 50,000 points per member per year, require identity verification on both sides, and revoke the right for any account with repeated disputes.

What would change our mind

We would change our mind if your programme is legally required to allow transferability, for example under stored value or gift card rules in your jurisdiction. In that case, refusing is not an option, and a tightly capped transfer with identity checks is better than an uncontrolled workaround. We would also change our mind if you have a large share of members who hold points in accounts they cannot access because of death or divorce, and you have no other legal process to reunite those points with the rightful household. Then a verified transfer on proof of death or court order, capped and irreversible, is better than losing the member and inviting complaints to a regulator.

Related