Decisions · Risk and fraud
Should you allow promotions to stack
No. Allow only one time-limited promotional lift on top of a member's standard earn or discount rate, and cap the combined value per member per month. Stacking beyond that turns a controlled incentive into an open-ended margin leak and trains members to wait for overlapping offers.
The decision
The decision is not whether members may earn base points and redeem them in the same transaction. That is normal programme behaviour. The question is whether two or more time-limited promotions, such as a double points offer and a category bonus, may apply to the same purchase at the same time. Allowing them to stack changes the programme's cost model from a set of separate, capped incentives to a single uncapped discount that scales with every overlap.
Mechanically, stacking means each offer computes its lift independently and then adds it to the others. Without a stack cap, a member who qualifies for three offers gets the sum of all three. The programme has no single point of control over the total value delivered per member per period. That is the thing to decide: will you set one maximum combined promotional value, or will you let each campaign set its own terms and hope the overlaps stay small.
What it costs you
The real cost is margin and liability. Every stacked percentage or multiplier compounds the programme's funding obligation. If you allow a five percent discount to stack with a ten percent discount, a 100 dollar basket costs you 15 dollars of gross margin instead of 10 dollars, and the member is no more loyal than a single 15 percent discount would have made them. The extra five dollars is pure leakage.
Illustrative calculation: a member earns one point per dollar, a double points promotion adds one extra point, and a travel category bonus adds two extra points. On a 500 dollar travel purchase, stacking all three gives 2,000 points. Applying only the highest single lift gives 1,500 points. The difference is 500 points. At 0.8 cents per point, that is 400 cents, or 4 dollars. Over 12 months, that is 48 dollars extra per member. At one cent per point, the annual extra is 60 dollars. Add service and engineering time for conflicting offer logic.
How to decide
Apply this test. Take your three highest-volume promotions and compute the combined value for a member who qualifies for all three on a typical 100 dollar basket. Set a hard cap on total promotional value per member per month. For each pair, if the stacked value exceeds the cap, disallow automatic stacking for that pair. If no pair exceeds the cap, allow stacking only up to the cap, with the system refusing further lifts.
The test forces you to define a single economic limit before writing offer terms. If you cannot name that cap in one sentence, you should not stack. A programme that cannot state the maximum combined value per member is not managing promotions; it is hoping they do not overlap.
What would change our mind
We would change our mind if you operate a programme where each promotional budget is owned by a different cost centre, and the combined discount is a deliberate bundle price rather than an accidental overlap. In that case stacking is acceptable if three conditions are met: the total promotional value is capped and shown as a single offer, the net margin after all stacked discounts stays above a stated floor that the finance team approves, and the programme reports stacked redemptions as one line item so the board can see the full cost.
We would also reverse this if a controlled test shows, over three consecutive quarters, that members who stack three or more promotions have higher net profit per member than members who receive a single equivalent discount of the same total value. That would prove stacking creates behavioural value beyond the arithmetic. Until that condition is met, the burden is on the programme to justify the extra liability.