Decisions · Partners and channel

Should you sell points to partners

Sell points to partners only when the wholesale price exceeds your expected redemption cost per point and the partnership reaches customers your own programme cannot acquire directly. Otherwise, refuse the deal. The recommendation flips when the partner pays less than liability and servicing, because that sale transfers cash today and cost later.

The decision

Selling points to partners means a partner pays your programme cash now in exchange for your promise to honour those points later with members. The actual decision is whether to issue your loyalty currency on someone else's terms, before any member has earned it through your own behaviour. The mechanism underneath is a timing swap: you receive revenue today and take on a redemption obligation that may sit on your books for months or years. The partner gets a cheap incentive; you get the liability.

What it costs you

The real cost is the redemption liability plus the operational burden of tracking and settling partner-issued points. Take an illustrative sale. Suppose your average redemption cost is 10 dollars per 1,000 points, or one cent per point. A partner offers 8 dollars per 1,000 points. If you sell 10 million points, you receive 80,000 dollars and create a redemption obligation of 100,000 dollars. The 20,000 dollar difference is a direct loss before any platform work, tax, or customer service. To break even, the wholesale price would have to be at least 10 dollars per 1,000 points, and that ignores the fixed cost of adding a partner.

There is also member trust. A member who earns points slowly watches a partner hand out the same points as a sign-up bonus, and the value of the member's balance drops in perception even if the nominal redemption rate holds. Engineering time matters too. Partner points require settlement feeds, fraud rules, and reconciliation before the first point can be sold. That capacity is not free and cannot be recovered unless the wholesale margin covers it.

How to decide

Apply this test before any agreement. Set your floor price at the expected redemption cost per point plus servicing cost, then add fifteen percent. A partner who cannot pay that floor is asking you to fund their acquisition. Then check whether the partner can prove it reaches a segment you cannot acquire for less than the wholesale margin. Accept only if both conditions hold: profitable price and true reach. If the partner fails either, refuse the sale.

What would change our mind

Our recommendation flips to refusing all partner sales if your points do not expire and your ledger cannot separate partner-issued points from member-earned points. Without expiry and separate tracking, no wholesale price can be priced confidently, because the liability has no end date and the arithmetic test cannot be repeated. Under that condition, the sensible answer is to keep your currency closed.

Related