Decisions · Risk and fraud
What should you do when points are stolen
Restore the member's stolen points immediately, freeze the compromised account, and require identity re-verification before re-enabling, within one business day, without demanding the member prove they were not at fault. Treat the theft as a ledger correction the programme controls; investigation can follow restoration.
The decision
The decision is not whether the member lied. It is whether the loyalty programme treats stolen points as a member problem or a ledger problem. Points are entries the programme alone can issue, adjust and revoke. A thief who drains a balance has exploited a credential or a gap in the programme's security, so the loss sits on the programme's side until a fraud investigation shows shared credentials or deliberate member negligence. The mechanism is the order of operations. Restoration first stops the clock on member anger and gives the programme time to investigate without losing the customer. Investigation first forces the member to carry the liability while the programme argues about fault.
What it costs you
The recommended path costs the redemption liability of the stolen amount plus a small engineering cost to freeze the account and force re-verification. It does not cost the margin of a lost customer, which is the real alternative. Consider an illustrative case. A member has 24,000 points stolen. At 0.5 cents per point, those points carry 120 dollars of redemption cost on the programme's books. If the programme delays restoration for three months, a member who would otherwise spend 1,200 dollars a year at a 10 percent margin produces 120 dollars of annual margin. The member who churns over a denied claim takes that 120 dollars to a competitor. Restoring the points costs 120 dollars now and keeps the 120 dollars of margin; refusing costs the same 120 dollars in lost margin and adds support time, complaint volume and a permanently sceptical member. The points liability is smaller when you factor that some restored points may go unredeemed, but never count that as profit: it is a timing benefit, not a reason to deny.
How to decide
Apply the ledger test. If your programme issues points as earned spend that members can redeem for goods at a published rate, treat a theft as a ledger error and restore first. If your points are a purely promotional grant with no redemption liability and no contract term, you can treat theft as a marketing loss and investigate first. Then compare two quantities: the redemption value of the stolen points and the contribution margin of one member who leaves. If the contribution margin over the next twelve months exceeds the redemption value, restoration first is the lower cost decision. Do not import a competitor's answer; run the numbers for your own redemption rate, margin and churn risk. Write the rule into your fraud playbook: any report of theft triggers a freeze, a one business day restoration of the stolen balance, and a post-restoration review for credential sharing.
What would change our mind
We would reverse to investigate-first if the programme has evidence that the member reused the same password across the loyalty account and a breached third party, because then the member's behaviour caused the compromise and restoration rewards insecure practice. We would also reverse if the stolen points carry no redemption liability on the programme's balance sheet and the programme explicitly states that points have no cash value and may be cancelled at any time, because there is then no member asset to restore, only a discretionary discount that the programme may reissue or not. The condition is not a higher fraud rate in general; it is individual evidence that the member, not the ledger, was the weak point.