Decisions · Tiers and status
Should tiers qualify on spend or activity
Tiers should qualify on spend. Spend is the only member signal that scales with the liability a tier creates, so it keeps elite benefits aligned with margin. Activity should be used only when a programme has fixed capacity that would otherwise go empty and activity itself drives ancillary revenue that exceeds the tier cost.
The decision
Tier qualification is a rationing rule. A programme has a fixed set of elite benefits, and every qualifier consumes some of them. The choice is whether to ration those benefits by the revenue a member brings or by the number of times she transacts. Spend qualification rations by contribution, activity qualification rations by presence. The mechanism underneath is not measurement difficulty; it is which behaviour the programme is willing to pay for. A spend threshold says the programme will pay for revenue. An activity threshold says the programme will pay for frequency even when frequency produces little revenue.
What it costs you
Spend qualification has a clear cost: you will reject some frequent low-fare members. That is a trust cost, not an accounting cost, and it should be admitted. If a member takes twenty flights a year at 100 dollars each, she spends 2,000 dollars. Under a spend threshold of 3,000 dollars she gets nothing, and she may conclude the programme no longer values her. Illustrative calculation: that member falls 1,000 dollars short of the threshold. The tier benefits she would have received under an activity rule cost, say, 150 dollars. A different member who takes four flights at 750 dollars each spends 3,000 dollars and qualifies. The same 150 dollars of benefits is 7.5 percent of the first member's revenue (150 divided by 2,000) but only 5 percent of the second member's revenue (150 divided by 3,000). Spend qualification accepts losing the 2,000 dollar member to avoid paying 150 dollars, or 7.5 percent of her revenue, for benefits that do not cover their own cost.
How to decide
Run a re-ranking test on your own data. Take every member who qualified for a tier under your current activity rule in the last twelve months. Re-rank them by spend, not by flights, nights or transactions. Find the bottom decile by spend among those qualifiers. Ask whether the tier benefits they consumed cost more than the margin their spend produced. If the bottom decile produced less margin than the tier cost, that is your evidence that activity is buying empty status. Set the spend threshold at the point where the tier cost equals the margin of the member you are willing to keep. That threshold will move with your benefit costs, which is exactly what you want.
What would change our mind
We would flip to activity qualification if a programme can show, from its own transaction data, that status-motivated activity generates ancillary margin that cannot be captured through spend. The test is precise: for the marginal activity qualifier, the ancillary revenue she generates per flight, night or transaction must exceed the cost of the tier benefits she consumes, and that excess must be greater than the excess from the marginal spend qualifier. If a hotel can demonstrate that a night-staying member who would not meet a spend threshold buys breakfast, parking and late checkout worth more than the room rate, activity qualification becomes correct. That is a real condition, not a hedge: the data either show the ancillary margin or they do not.