Decisions · Tiers and status

Should tier qualification roll over

Yes, but only with a cap. Allow members to roll over the qualifying activity they earned above this year's tier threshold, up to half of one year's requirement, and only if they actually qualified in the current period. Full or uncapped rollover turns an annual test into a stored balance and weakens the tier.

The decision

The decision is whether this year's unused qualifying activity becomes a balance that reduces next year's tier requirement. The mechanism underneath is the annual reset: status is meant to prove current-year value, not cumulative value. Rollover changes that reset into a stored credit, so the real choice is between an annual test and a cumulative balance. We recommend a stored credit that is limited by a cap, not an open-ended balance. The cap matters more than the rollover itself.

What it costs you

The price is not zero. The programme must build carryover tracking, set the cap before launch, and accept that future tier liability will increase. Members will compare the offered cap to what a rival programme allows, so a cap set too low can damage trust.

Illustrative calculation: a top tier requires 100,000 qualifying points in a calendar year. A 50 per cent cap allows 50,000 points to carry forward. A member who earns 140,000 points has 40,000 excess points, all of which roll over. Next year she needs 60,000 new points instead of 100,000. If the marginal liability of one tier point is 0.015 dollars, that carried balance is 600 dollars. The rolled points cover exactly 40 per cent of next year's requirement, so the annual reset is softened by 40 per cent.

That 600 dollars is a real future cost. It also removes 40 per cent of next year's revenue requirement from that account, which lowers the margin on her next-year qualifying spend. If the cap were removed, an account could bank several years of excess and qualify without any current-year spend. The cap prevents that.

How to decide

Look at the final quarter of your qualification year. If members who have already reached their tier threshold stop earning qualifying activity, a capped rollover of the excess above threshold will recover some of that lost revenue. Set the cap at the lower of half the annual requirement or the member's actual excess. If tracking excess per account costs more than the recovered margin, keep the annual reset. Run this test on two consecutive years before committing.

What would change our mind

If the incremental margin from the spend that earns each carried point is lower than the future liability and servicing cost of that point, we would reverse and recommend no rollover at all. In that case the annual reset is cheaper than storing status credit.

Related