Decisions · Partners and channel
Should you sell points to your issuer
Yes, sell points to your issuer as the primary funding line, but only with a hard price floor above your marginal redemption cost and a volume cap tied to expected redemptions. Without that floor, issuer sales quietly transfer programme margin to the bank; with it, the sale funds growth without diluting member value.
The decision
The decision is whether a loyalty programme should accept cash from its card issuer now in exchange for a promise to supply points that will be redeemed later. The mechanism is a forward sale of a private currency. The issuer pays now, cardholders earn and accrue points, and the programme recognises revenue while carrying a redemption liability that matures over several years. This is not a simple sale of inventory. The programme is underwriting its own future redemptions, so the price must cover more than the current cash need.
What it costs you
The balance sheet obligation is the first cost. Every point sold increases future redemptions, which must be fulfilled with partner inventory, cash transfers or travel stock. If the contract price sits below the scheme's marginal fulfilment expense, each unit erodes margin immediately. Member trust erodes when the issuer floods the programme with newly purchased points and award inventory tightens. Engineering capacity gets consumed by reconciliation, settlement files and audit queries from the bank, not by member improvements. An illustrative calculation shows the sensitivity. Suppose the scheme sells 10,000,000 points at one cent each, receiving 100,000 dollars. Expected breakage is 20 percent, so 8,000,000 points redeem. Average fulfilment expense is 0.75 cents, so expected cost equals 60,000 dollars. Gross margin is 40,000 dollars. If redemption rate climbs to 90 percent, redeemed points become 9,000,000, cost becomes 67,500 dollars and margin falls to 32,500 dollars, a drop of 7,500 dollars or 18.75 percent. The liability does not scale linearly with cash received.
How to decide
Apply a three part test to any issuer contract. First, compute your marginal fulfilment cost per point, including partner settlement, fraud and customer service touches. Second, set a floor price at least 20 percent above that cost. Third, cap total points sold to the issuer at no more than 12 months of expected redemptions. If the contract meets all three, sell. If any condition fails, renegotiate or decline, because the issuer is buying at a price that does not cover your obligation.
What would change our mind
We would reverse this recommendation if the marginal cost of fulfilling an additional point becomes non-linear and exceeds the contract price at the proposed volume. That happens when selling another million points forces you to add a new partner, expand call centre shifts or buy premium award seats at retail. A fixed floor price is useless if your cost curve bends upward. If the issuer demands a price below that marginal cost, or if the contract requires unlimited volume, the correct answer is no.