Decisions · Risk and fraud
Should you allow resellers to earn loyalty rewards
Do not allow resellers to earn loyalty rewards on stock bought for resale. Allow rewards only when a reseller buys as an end customer for its own use, on a retail invoice at retail price.
The decision
The decision is whether loyalty currency should accrue on purchases made for resale, not for use. The mechanism is margin transfer. A reseller buying stock already receives a trade price. Loyalty rewards are a further discount paid from retail margin. If the reseller earns points on that stock and later redeems them as a consumer, the programme funds a consumer benefit from a wholesale transaction. The rule must split the account, not the person. Allow rewards on own use at retail price, disallow on stock bought for resale.
What it costs you
The recommended path costs engineering time and operating capacity because you must classify purchases and defend the split. The main risk is not the reseller who asks, it is the mixed account that buys both stock and own-use items. You need a transaction attribute for reward eligibility, not just a customer segment.
This is illustrative. Suppose a reseller with a trade account buys 20,000 dollars of own-use goods at retail price and earns one point per dollar. At ten points to one dollar, that creates a 2,000 dollar liability. If the programme margin on those goods is 30 percent, the transaction generates 6,000 dollars of margin, so the reward costs one third of it. Now suppose the same account is wrongly allowed to earn on 50,000 dollars of stock at 15 percent margin. That creates a 5,000 dollar liability. The stock purchase generates 7,500 dollars of margin, so the reward consumes two thirds of it, leaving 2,500 dollars. To correct the error you spend 200 dollars in support time and 1,000 dollars in engineering time to reclassify, or 1,200 dollars against that remaining margin.
Member trust suffers when ordinary members learn that trade buyers earned rewards on purchases they could not make at those prices. The fix is visible eligibility rules, not hidden exclusions.
How to decide
Ask whether the goods are bought with intent to resell or to consume. If the invoice is a trade invoice and the items are held as inventory, no rewards. If the invoice is a retail invoice and the items are for the buyer's own use, rewards apply. The test is the invoice and the inventory, not the buyer's identity. Run a monthly query for any account with a reseller flag that earned points on trade terms. If that query returns a positive number, your split is not enforced.
What would change our mind
We would reverse this if the programme could settle rewards on stock purchases as an immediate trade discount, not as a convertible consumer currency. That would require stock purchase margin to be at least as high as retail redemption margin plus programme operating cost, and for liabilities to be recognised and settled on the same invoice. If a loyalty programme did that, rewarding stock purchases would be neutral instead of margin leakage.