Decisions · Economics and liability
Should you rely on a breakage assumption
No. Do not rely on a breakage assumption to release liability or fund a loyalty programme. Recognise breakage only when member behaviour shows an established pattern of non-redemption, and even then keep the assumption conservative and reversible.
The decision
The decision is whether to treat some outstanding points as unlikely to be redeemed and to reduce the programme liability before members actually forfeit them. The mechanism is accounting for loyalty points as a deferred revenue obligation. The issuer owes future goods or services for every point outstanding. A breakage assumption reclassifies part of that obligation as revenue or as a lower cost of sales. The underlying question is whether the behaviour of silent members is predictable enough to justify releasing that obligation early.
What it costs you
If you refuse to rely on breakage, you keep the full value of outstanding points on the liability side. Your current profit is lower and your balance sheet carries more obligation. That is the real cost of the recommended path. You may also need to reserve more cash or reduce distributions while you wait for redemption data.
One illustrative calculation shows the size of that cost. Suppose a programme has one million points outstanding, each worth one cent, so the full liability is 10,000 dollars. A 25 percent breakage assumption would release 2,500 dollars into profit now. Declining to use it keeps that 2,500 dollars as a liability. If actual redemption then runs 10 percentage points above the assumed rate, the issuer needs an additional 1,000 dollars to satisfy members. Full liability from the start keeps that 1,000 dollars available before demand appears.
There is also an operating cost. You will maintain expiry logic and redemption data even if you do not use them for early profit. That engineering time is the price of treating the liability as real. A programme that ignores breakage must still model future redemptions to manage cash, so the work is not avoided.
How to decide
Apply this test to your own programme. First, identify whether points have a fixed expiry date or are perpetual. If perpetual, there is no externally imposed forfeiture event, so breakage must come from observed member abandonment. Second, compare redemption rates across the last several completed periods. If they vary by more than a few percentage points, you do not yet have a stable base. Third, ask whether the liability is material enough that releasing a portion would change reported profit by a noticeable amount. If all three point toward stability and immateriality, you may consider a conservative recognition. If any one fails, hold the full liability.
What would change our mind
We would change our mind only if three conditions were met. The points would need a fixed expiry date written into the terms, with no promise to reinstate or extend them. Redemption behaviour would need to be stable across several complete expiry cycles, not merely projected from one short period. And the accounting treatment would need to be accepted by the programme's auditor or regulator as a reduction of the obligation before expiry. Without all three, the safer position remains holding full liability.