Decisions · Economics and liability
Should loyalty rewards be funded by you or a partner
Fund rewards from your own balance sheet whenever the outstanding liability is small enough to carry without cutting other investment. That keeps member data, redemption values and programme economics under your control, and partner funding should only be used for incremental rewards you would not otherwise offer.
The decision
The decision is where the liability for reward redemption sits: on your books or on a partner's. When you fund rewards, you issue points or credits that are a promise you must honour later. When a partner funds them, the partner owns the redemption promise and typically sets the catalogue, the transfer values and the data flows. The mechanism underneath is not just accounting; it is control. A self-funded programme gives you the ability to change earn rates, devalue points on a schedule you set, and keep the full margin on any breakage. A partner-funded programme gives you a lower cash outlay today in exchange for giving up those levers.
What it costs you
Self-funding costs you the carrying cost of the liability and the operating capacity to run redemptions. The main number is your outstanding points liability. This is illustrative. Say a programme has an outstanding points liability of 2 million dollars. If you hold that liability for six months and your cost of capital is 5 percent a year, the carrying cost is 50,000 dollars. A partner who funds those same redemptions will often take 20 percent of redeemed value, which is 400,000 dollars if every point is eventually redeemed. That difference of 350,000 dollars is the price of control, and it does not include the margin you lose when the partner marks up its own redemptions.
Self-funding also demands engineering time to maintain a redemption catalogue and the discipline to account for liability. Partner funding appears cheaper because the partner builds that catalogue, but the partner will use the redemption moment to advertise its own products, diluting your member relationship. The true cost is not the 50,000 dollars; it is the loss of control over the one moment when your member feels the programme working.
How to decide
Apply this test to your own programme. Take the last 12 months of points issued, multiply by your expected redemption cost per point, and write down the total as a liability in dollars. Then take the partner's proposed commission on all partner-funded redemptions, also in dollars. If your annual carrying cost of that liability, using your own cost of capital, is lower than the partner's commission, and you have the engineering capacity to operate a basic redemption catalogue, fund rewards yourself. If either of those fails, partner funding is the correct fallback.
A second test is data. If you are not willing to hand over your members' redemption history to a partner that also sells to them, self-funding is the only route. That is a yes or no question.
What would change our mind
The recommendation flips when your outstanding liability exceeds what your balance sheet can absorb without harming other investment. A concrete trigger is when the liability grows beyond 10 percent of your annual revenue and you have no direct redemption assets such as flights, rooms or physical goods. In that situation, self-funding no longer buys you control; it buys you a contingent debt that can force you to cut acquisition or product spend. Then the partner's margin is cheaper than the risk of running out of cash to honour points.