Decisions · Earn and redemption
Should you offer points plus cash redemption
Yes. Offer points plus cash redemption when outstanding point liability is high relative to annual redemptions and the cash portion can be priced above fulfilment cost. It lifts redemption, reduces liability, and adds cash margin, but only if you publish a fixed points value.
The decision
The choice is whether to allow partial settlement of a reward with a money top-up. Under this structure, an account holder with too few points for a reward pays the difference in currency. The mechanism is a two leg transaction: points reduce the price, and the top-up covers the outlay for providing the reward plus a small profit. This shifts the point balance from a deferred obligation into an active payment method.
What it costs you
The recommended route consumes engineering capacity, because checkout and refund logic must split tender and restore the same ratio. It eats margin if the cash leg is priced under the variable cost of the good. It damages trust if the value of a point moves between offers. The gain is that booked obligation falls faster. This is illustrative. Take a scheme with 400 million points outstanding, booked at 0.9 cents each, so 3.6 million dollars of obligation. Before this feature, 10 per cent of points are spent each year. After launch, that rises to 15 per cent, an extra 20 million points spent. Obligation drops by 180,000 dollars, which is 20 million points times 0.009 dollars. If the average cash leg equals half the point value at 1.1 cents per point, the scheme receives 110,000 dollars, which is 20 million points times 0.011 dollars times 0.5. The combined effect before fulfilment cost is 290,000 dollars.
How to decide
Measure two things on your own books. First, take the outstanding point balance per active account. Second, take the trailing twelve month spend rate. If the first number is above twelve months of net points earned and the second is below 20 per cent, add this feature. If both are already strong, the extra build complexity is not worth the small movement in deferred cost. A modest gap between balance and reward is the signal for this feature; a large gap means earning is the problem.
What would change our mind
We would flip to no when the additional payment cannot be priced above the outlay for the reward after counting the obligation relief. In the example above, that threshold is a contribution under 1.45 cents per unit on the extra spending, because the obligation relief alone is 0.9 cents and the average additional payment is 0.55 cents. If your catalogue runs on thin margins, this feature becomes a discount that steals full cash sales, and the better lever is stronger earning or better reward value.