Decisions · Strategy and governance

When is loyalty the wrong answer

Loyalty is the wrong answer when a business already receives repeat custom through necessity, contract, or structural convenience rather than customer choice. A programme in that setting adds reward cost without changing behaviour, so the recommendation is to avoid launching one and to spend the budget on the actual constraint instead.

The decision

The decision is whether a loyalty programme can act as a demand-shaping tool or whether it only adds a discount layer to purchases that would happen anyway. The mechanism underneath is accumulated reward value: a member trades a small future benefit for a present choice. That mechanism works only when the next purchase is genuinely discretionary. If the customer returns because a contract requires it, a regulator mandates it, or the practical cost of switching is higher than the reward, then the loyalty programme has no choice to influence. The points become a retrospective thank you, not a forward incentive, and the programme is the wrong answer.

What it costs you

A loyalty programme in a locked-in business creates liability and margin pressure without a compensating behaviour change. You must carry unredeemed points on the balance sheet, build expiry and ledger systems, answer member enquiries about points that never change decisions, and eventually explain any devaluation. The cost is not just the reward itself; it is the operating capacity absorbed by tracking a currency that does no work.

One illustrative calculation: assume a member spends 2,000 dollars a year and earns one point per dollar, with each point redeemable at one cent. That is 2,000 points worth 20 dollars. If 75 per cent of points are redeemed, the expected cash cost is 15 dollars per member. The remaining 5 dollars per member sits as deferred liability. That liability still requires expiry tracking and customer support even though it will never be redeemed.

The larger hidden cost is member trust. When a customer must buy from you anyway and receives points, the points are seen as an entitlement. Later caps or expiry are experienced as a broken promise even though no behaviour changed.

How to decide

The test is to remove the programme and ask whether a meaningful share of customers would still buy from a competitor at the same price and effort. If yes, loyalty may be the right lever. If no, then the programme is not shaping demand; it is subsidising captivity. A second check is to name the customer behaviour the points are meant to change. If you cannot name one specific, observable action that would not happen without the points, do not build it. The answer is wrong when the only behaviour the programme rewards is the one the contract already forces.

What would change our mind

Our recommendation flips if the programme can attach the loyalty currency to a scarce resource that customers value separately from price, such as priority access, waived constraints, or a service level that is genuinely rationed. In that case the reward changes access rather than discounting an unavoidable purchase, and the mechanism starts to shape behaviour. The moment the benefit is only points for cash, loyalty remains the wrong answer.

Related