Decisions · Earn and redemption
Should your points expire, and on what trigger
Yes. Expire points after 24 months of no earning or redemption activity, not on a fixed calendar date. Activity-based expiry clears dormant balances that would otherwise sit as an unhedged loyalty liability, while fixed-date expiry punishes active members whose points happen to cross a calendar boundary.
The decision
Most loyalty programmes ask the wrong question. They ask whether points should expire, as if expiry were a single switch. The actual decision is what event removes a point balance: a calendar date or a member's continued inactivity. A fixed date expires every balance on the same day, regardless of whether the member earned points yesterday or three years ago. An activity trigger expires a balance only after a defined stretch with no earning and no redemption. The mechanism underneath is liability ageing. A point balance is a promise to provide future value; if the member has stopped interacting, that promise becomes an unliquidated liability with no offsetting engagement. Activity-based expiry matches the liability to the member's actual behaviour instead of an arbitrary cliff.
What it costs you
Activity-based expiry is not free. You need a reliable last-activity timestamp on every account, a nightly job that flags balances older than your threshold, a notice sequence by email or app message, and a reversal path for members who return and complain. Illustrative arithmetic shows the trade-off. Suppose your programme carries 80,000 dormant accounts with an average balance of 1,500 points and a liability value of one cent per point. That is 120,000,000 points, or 1,200,000 dollars in outstanding redemption liability. If an activity trigger removes 70 percent of those balances after notice, liability falls by 840,000 dollars. The build costs three developer months at 12,000 dollars each, totalling 36,000 dollars, plus two support months at 5,000 dollars each, totalling 10,000 dollars. Net saving is 794,000 dollars before any make-good. If 4 percent of expired members return and you restore their original balances, that is 3,200 members times 15 dollars per member, or 48,000 dollars. The net liability reduction remains 746,000 dollars. The real cost is in member trust and engineering capacity, not in the points themselves.
How to decide
Count the median time between a member's first earn and their last redemption before they lapse. If that median is under 24 months, set the inactivity trigger at 24 months with a 90-day notice period. Require any earning or redemption event, not a login or app open, to reset the timer. If you cannot capture last-activity timestamps reliably from your ledger, do not adopt an activity trigger. If you can, run a shadow expiry for one quarter before deleting balances: flag accounts, send the notice sequence, and measure how many members return. Adopt the trigger only if fewer than 10 percent of flagged members return with a complaint. Otherwise lengthen the trigger or improve the notice.
What would change our mind
Our recommendation flips if points are predominantly partner-funded and recognised as revenue at issuance rather than as a liability. In that structure, an unredeemed point does not sit on your balance sheet; it is a partner's marketing cost. The case for activity-based expiry weakens because the liability argument disappears, and a fixed calendar expiry aligned to partner contract terms becomes simpler and cheaper. A second flip condition is a statutory minimum validity period longer than 24 months, such as a consumer protection rule that forbids expiry before three years. Under that rule, you must extend the inactivity trigger to the legal minimum or abandon expiry entirely; no accounting argument overrides the regulation.