Decisions · Strategy and governance
Should your loyalty programme be proactive or reactionary
Be proactive where your data can fire a rule and reach the member before their next decision. A programme that anticipates dormancy, redemption friction and service failure keeps liability lower and member trust higher than one that waits for complaints. If your signals cannot act within the member's cycle, stay reactionary until they can.
The decision
The decision is not whether to send more messages or fewer. It is whether the programme's operating loop runs on observed behaviour after the fact or on predicted behaviour before the fact. Proactive rules fire when a member has not yet lapsed, not yet complained, not yet missed a redemption window. Reactionary rules fire when the member has already done one of those things. The mechanism underneath is the timing of the intervention relative to the member's decision point. If the intervention arrives before that point, it changes the decision. If it arrives after, it only manages the consequence.
What it costs you
Proactive costs operating capacity first. You need staff or automation to watch early-warning signals and act while the member still has the next decision in front of them. It also costs engineering time to build the rules that distinguish a member who is about to lapse from one who is merely quiet. And it costs margin when you issue points before the member has asked for anything, because a proactive bonus is a real liability, not a marketing promise.
An illustrative calculation: suppose an account at risk of dormancy would otherwise stop earning for six months. At 100 points a month, that is 600 points of foregone accrual. If 20 percent of dormant accounts never come back, the programme carries 120 points of breakage liability that reactionary service will not touch until the expiry period ends. A proactive save that costs 30 points in a bonus removes that 120 points, leaving 90 points of liability removed per account rescued. That 90 points is not margin. It is the price of not having to rebuild trust after the member has already left.
How to decide
Apply this test to each member journey, not to the programme as a whole. Can you fire a rule on a member's last three transactions and have an action reach them before the next likely transaction? If yes, go proactive for that journey. If your data is refreshed only monthly or your approval chain takes two weeks, stay reactionary for that journey until the cycle time drops below the member's decision interval. The answer will differ between a high-frequency coffee stamp card and an annual insurance renewal.
What would change our mind
We would flip to reactionary if proactive interventions produce a higher cost per retained account than the lifetime margin of that account over the same period. The condition is measurable: run a split where one group receives proactive triggers and the other does not, and if the proactive group shows no lower dormancy and redeems less margin per account, then reactionary wins. Or if member trust falls after unsolicited contact in a way that depresses future redemption, not just current complaints, the proactive default becomes the wrong default.