Learn · Tiers and benefits

Choosing benefits people want

Choose benefits by matching them to your best members' habits and complaints. Score each candidate on perceived value and variable cost per redemption. Prefer benefits that are easy to redeem and reinforce frequent purchase behaviour. Test a shortlist with a sample of members and measure redemption before rolling out.

How it works

Choosing benefits people want starts with your best members' existing behaviour. List what your highest value customers already buy, how often they visit, and what friction they complain about. Then score each candidate benefit on two numbers: perceived value to the member and variable cost to you. A strong benefit feels worth more than it costs you to deliver and is easy to redeem without staff confusion. Prefer benefits that reinforce a behaviour you want to keep, such as a free add-on for frequent buyers, over one-off gifts that do not change behaviour. Benefits fall into three practical groups: money off, time saved, and recognition. Money off includes discount vouchers or free upgrades. Time saved includes priority queues or early access. Recognition includes a handwritten note or a named account manager. The best mix usually includes one from each group, but only if each benefit passes the cost and redemption test.

Worked example

This is an illustrative example. A programme has 1,000 gold members. Benefit A, a free extra product add-on, costs GBP 3 per redemption and is expected to be used by 400 members once a year. Benefit B, a birthday gift, costs GBP 5 per redemption and is expected to be used by 900 members once a year. Benefit A costs GBP 1,200 and delivers perceived value of GBP 5 per use, so total perceived value is GBP 2,000. Benefit B costs GBP 4,500 and delivers perceived value of GBP 10 per use, so total perceived value is GBP 9,000. Benefit B has a higher total cost but a better perceived value to cost ratio, 2.0 against 1.67, so it is the stronger choice if the budget allows. Now consider a third candidate, Benefit C, early access to sales, which has zero variable cost but requires one hour of staff set-up per event. If there are 12 events a year and staff time costs GBP 20 per hour, Benefit C costs GBP 240 per year. If 800 members use early access and each values it at GBP 0.50 per event, total perceived value is 800 times 12 times GBP 0.50, which is GBP 4,800. Benefit C has the best ratio of perceived value to cost, so it belongs in the shortlist.

What to do

First, audit your top 20 percent of members by value and record their three most common purchases and their biggest service complaint. Second, shortlist no more than five benefits that fall into three groups: save money, save time, or feel recognised. Third, cost each benefit per redemption, not per member, and estimate how many times it will be used per year. Fourth, ask a sample of members to rank the shortlist before you commit. Fifth, run a small pilot for 60 days and measure redemption rate and any change in tier qualification behaviour. Drop benefits that fewer than 10 percent of eligible members use or that cause repeated support questions. Sixth, review the pilot results with front line staff, because they know which benefits cause friction at the till or in the app. Seventh, decide on no more than three benefits for your first tier and write a one line promise for each, such as free next day delivery on orders over GBP 50. Then set a review date in six months to measure actual redemption and member feedback.

Common mistakes

  • Copying benefits from other programmes without checking whether your own members value them.
  • Offering too many benefits, which spreads your budget thin and makes the programme hard to explain.
  • Choosing benefits that are hard to redeem, such as requiring a code or a manager's approval at every use.
  • Ignoring the operational burden on staff, which turns a well intended benefit into a source of friction.

Related