Learn · Economics

Costing your benefits

Cost each benefit by adding every direct cost you incur to deliver one redemption. Include supplier price, shipping to you, packaging, postage to the member, and any transaction or processing fees. Exclude fixed overheads that do not change with redemptions. Use this per-unit figure to compare benefits and set sustainable earn rates.

How it works

Costing a benefit means finding the full direct cost you pay when one member redeems it. Start with the supplier price you pay for the goods or service. Add any cost to get that item ready for the member, such as shipping from your supplier, warehousing only if you pay per unit, packaging, postage to the member, and any payment processing fee. Exclude fixed overheads like head office rent or staff salaries that stay the same however many redemptions occur. For a service benefit, include the paid staff time and any consumables used during delivery. Build a cost card for each benefit so you can compare options on the same basis. This direct cost, not the retail price, is the number that flows into your earn rate and margin calculations.

Worked example

The following arithmetic is illustrative. Say you offer two benefits: a 25 dollar gift card and a branded tote bag. For the gift card, you buy it at a 10 percent discount, so your supplier price is 25 dollars minus 2 dollars 50 cents, which equals 22 dollars 50 cents. You also pay a processing fee of 50 cents per card, giving a total cost of 23 dollars per redemption. For the tote bag, the supplier charges 4 dollars 20 cents per bag, shipping to your warehouse costs 80 cents per bag, and packaging plus postage to the member costs 3 dollars 50 cents. The tote bag totals 8 dollars 50 cents per redemption. These two figures let you compare benefits directly, even though one has a higher perceived retail value.

What to do

Create a simple spreadsheet with one row per benefit and columns for supplier cost, inbound shipping, packaging, postage, processing fee, and other variable costs. Fill in each column from actual invoices or price lists, not from estimated retail values. For products you already sell, use the marginal wholesale cost rather than an allocated full cost. For services, measure the staff minutes required and multiply by the loaded hourly wage. Review the sheet every quarter and whenever a supplier changes price, postage rates move, or you alter packaging. When comparing a new benefit, complete the same cost card before you decide to add it. Keep a note of the date and source for each cost so you can trace changes later.

Common mistakes

  • Using the retail price as your cost, which overstates the economic burden of a benefit you supply yourself.
  • Forgetting fulfilment costs like postage, packaging, or payment processing, which can turn a seemingly cheap benefit into an expensive one.
  • Allocating a share of fixed overheads such as warehouse rent to each redemption, which hides the true incremental cost and distorts comparisons.
  • Costing a benefit once at launch and never updating it, so supplier price rises silently erode your margin.

Related