Learn · Economics
Liability basics for beginners
A loyalty liability is the estimated future cost of points or rewards members have earned but not yet redeemed. Beginners must record this as a balance sheet obligation when points are issued, not when customers redeem them. Getting the estimate and the timing wrong understates costs and can mislead anyone reading the accounts.
How it works
When a member earns points on a purchase, you have not simply given a discount today. You have accepted an obligation to provide something of value later. Accounting rules require you to estimate the cost of fulfilling those unredeemed points and show that amount as a liability. Each period you adjust the estimate: add for new points earned, subtract for points redeemed or expired, and revise for changes in expected redemption rates or cost per point. The liability is not the face value of points; it is your cost to provide the reward, often less than the retail value. For a simple coffee shop programme, if a member earns 100 points and each point is expected to cost you one cent to fulfil, you record one dollar of liability, not the two dollars of revenue you might have recognised. This separates today's sales from tomorrow's cost.
Worked example
The following is illustrative arithmetic. A retailer issues one point per dollar spent. Members spend 50,000 dollars in a month, earning 50,000 points. If the expected redemption rate is 80 percent and the estimated cost to fulfil is 0.8 cents per point, the new liability is 50,000 points times 0.8 times 0.008 dollars, which equals 320 dollars. During the same month, 5,000 points are redeemed at an actual cost of 0.7 cents per point, so the liability is reduced by 5,000 times 0.007 dollars, which equals 35 dollars. Starting liability was 100 dollars, so the closing liability is 100 plus 320 minus 35, which equals 385 dollars.
What to do
First choose the earning event. Decide whether points attach at sale, at referral, or at sign-up, and fix the earning rate before launch. Next build a cost per point model from the actual cost of goods or services you will give away, not from their retail price. Set a redemption assumption using your own programme history if available, otherwise start with a conservative low rate and adjust upwards as redemption behaviour appears. At the end of each month, calculate opening liability plus new points earned multiplied by cost per point and expected redemption, minus redemptions and expirations. Record the adjustment through a liability account and an offsetting expense or deferred revenue account. Finally, reconcile the closing balance against a roll-forward of points outstanding and investigate any difference.
Common mistakes
- Treating points as a marketing expense only when redeemed, so the liability is never recorded at the time points are earned.
- Using the retail value of the reward instead of the cost to fulfil, which overstates the liability and distorts profit.
- Assuming every point will be redeemed, ignoring breakage from expiration and inactive accounts, so the liability is too high.
- Failing to update the redemption rate after the first months of actual behaviour, so the balance drifts from a best estimate.