Learn · Getting started
Points, tiers or paid
Points, tiers or paid refers to three loyalty mechanics: earn points per purchase, unlock tier benefits by cumulative activity, or pay a recurring fee for enhanced rewards. Most first programmes should start with simple earn-and-burn points before adding paid tiers once member behaviour is clear.
How it works
Points programmes award a fixed number of points for each dollar or purchase. Members accumulate points and convert them into rewards such as vouchers, products, or account credit. Tiers group members by cumulative spend or visits over a rolling period, usually twelve months. Each tier unlocks a set of permanent benefits, like priority service or a higher earning rate. Paid programmes charge an upfront subscription fee in exchange for a defined package of advantages, often including free delivery, member pricing, or bonus points.
For a first programme, points are the easiest to operate because the unit value is easy to communicate and the liability is deferred until a member redeems. Tiers require you to forecast how many members reach each level and to fund the additional perks, which adds complexity. Paid membership shifts value to the member at sign-up, so the fee must clearly exceed the annual cost of the benefits delivered, otherwise retention suffers. You can combine models later, but starting with one model prevents confusion and makes the earning arithmetic transparent.
Worked example
This is an illustrative example, not a real result. A member spends 100 dollars per month. Under a points model with one point per dollar, she earns 100 points each month and 1,200 points over a year. If 1,000 points convert to a 10 dollar voucher, her annual reward value is 10 dollars with 200 points carried forward. Under a tier model, the same annual spend of 1,200 dollars reaches a bronze tier at 1,000 dollars, which pays a 2 per cent rebate on the remaining 200 dollars. That rebate equals 4 dollars. Under a paid model, she pays 50 dollars per year for a 5 per cent discount on all spend. Her annual discount on 1,200 dollars is 60 dollars, leaving a net gain of 10 dollars after the fee.
What to do
First, choose one model. Calculate the average monthly spend of a typical member using your own transaction data, not an industry figure. Set the earning rate and redemption threshold so that a member receives a meaningful reward within three to six months. If you choose points, define a fixed value per point and display it next to the point balance. If you choose tiers, set no more than three levels and make the entry threshold reachable for your median member within one year. If you choose paid, list the benefits that have a clear dollar value and price the fee below that value by at least 20 per cent.
Second, write the member-facing rules before launch. State how points are earned, when they expire, and how redemption works. For tiers, state the qualification period and how status is reviewed. For paid membership, state the cancellation and refund policy in plain language. Then run a paper test with five sample member profiles. Calculate the reward value for a low spender, a median spender, and a high spender to confirm that the model does not overpay one segment.
After launch, track redemption rate, average time to first reward, and tier movement each month. Adjust only one parameter at a time, such as the earning rate or the threshold, and announce changes at least 30 days ahead.
Common mistakes
- Launching a points programme with a redemption catalogue that is empty or unclear at day one, which delays the first reward and weakens trust.
- Setting tier thresholds so high that most members never see a change in status during the first year, which makes the tier structure irrelevant.
- Pricing a paid membership above the dollar value of the included benefits, so members calculate a net loss and cancel after one period.
- Changing point values or expiry rules without notice, which can trigger complaints and reduce future participation.