Learn · Technology and vendors

Questions to ask a vendor

Ask a vendor about data ownership, export format, integration with your till and ecommerce, and what happens if you cancel. Confirm the cost model: setup fee, monthly base, per-member messaging, and any percentage of reward liability. Request a sandbox trial with your own transaction file and a reference from a programme of similar size. Written answers beat verbal promises.

How it works

A vendor question should test the exact earning and redemption logic you plan to run. Write down one or two rules, such as earning one point per dollar spent and allowing redemption only above 250 points. Then ask the vendor to configure those rules in a sandbox without custom code. If they cannot, the platform will drive your programme design instead of serving it.

Commercial questions matter as much as technical ones. Every point you issue becomes a future cost, so ask how the vendor charges for points outstanding, points redeemed, member messaging, and staff accounts. Also ask whether you can export member balances, transaction history, and campaign results at any time, and whether that export is in a practical format like CSV. A vendor that avoids written pricing or data export answers is signalling a future lock-in.

Operational fit is tested through failure cases. Ask what happens when a cashier scans a loyalty barcode after a return, when a member changes email address, and when two households share one phone number. Request the vendor's standard support hours and response time for a point balance error. A live walkthrough with your own sample receipts reveals more than a polished demo.

Worked example

This worked example is illustrative arithmetic. A programme has 1,200 members who spend on average 80 dollars per month. If they earn 1 point per dollar and each point is worth 1 cent when redeemed, the monthly reward liability is 960 dollars (1,200 members times 80 dollars times 1 cent). A vendor that charges a monthly base fee of 250 dollars plus 1.5 percent of reward liability would add 14.40 dollars in percentage fees, for a total of 264.40 dollars per month. Ask whether that base fee includes unlimited member emails, or whether you will pay another fee for each monthly campaign.

What to do

  1. Write a one-page brief that states your earn rule, redemption value, point expiry, and whether members can earn and redeem in store, online, or both.
  2. Send the same brief to three or four vendors and ask each to reply with a written configuration plan, not a generic sales brochure.
  3. Request itemised pricing for setup, monthly base, per-member messaging, and any percentage of points outstanding or redeemed.
  4. Test each shortlisted vendor in a sandbox using a spreadsheet of 20 sample transactions, including returns, partial payments, and expired points.
  5. Ask for a signed data ownership clause that names the export file format and the process for moving member balances to another vendor.
  6. Speak with a current user of similar size and ask which support issue took the longest to resolve and why.

Common mistakes

  • Asking for a list of features instead of testing your own earn and burn rules through a sample purchase.
  • Ignoring data ownership clauses, which can leave you unable to export member balances without paying an exit fee.
  • Comparing only the monthly base fee and failing to model reward liability, redemption fees, or per-message charges.
  • Choosing a vendor that cannot reverse a transaction cleanly, causing incorrect point balances that members quickly notice.

Related