Learn · Tiers and benefits
Setting thresholds
Setting thresholds means choosing the point, spend, or activity levels that unlock rewards, tiers, or benefits. Good thresholds make an early redemption feel attainable for a typical member while protecting programme economics. They should be based on your actual margins and member behaviour, not copied from another brand.
How it works
Thresholds are numerical gates in your loyalty rules. You define an earning rate, such as ten points for every dollar a member spends. You also define what happens when a member's earned points cross a chosen number, for example two thousand points unlocks a twenty dollar voucher. Thresholds can also apply to cumulative spend within a period, such as five hundred dollars in a calendar quarter to earn a higher tier. For a first programme, static thresholds are easiest to explain and operate. The key is to place each threshold above the spend of a very casual member but below what a typical engaged member can reach in about three months. This keeps the goal visible and credible while limiting early redemption cost.
Worked example
This worked example is illustrative arithmetic. Consider a bookshop that gives five points for every dollar spent. A ten dollar credit requires one thousand points, because each point carries a redemption value of one cent. Suppose a typical member spends sixty dollars per month, earning three hundred points. Reaching one thousand points takes three and one-third months. If the bookshop also introduces a five hundred point threshold for a five dollar credit, the same member reaches it in one and two-thirds months. That lower threshold creates an earlier reward moment, but it costs half as much per redemption and may happen twice as often. Assume the shop's gross margin is forty percent, so the shop can compare which threshold better covers the cost of the discount.
What to do
Start by calculating the average monthly spend of your active members and your gross margin per transaction in cents. Choose a simple earning rate, for example one point per dollar or ten points per dollar, and fix the cash value of one point at one cent. Set the first redemption threshold so that a typical member who spends at the average rate can reach it within three months. Work out the expected redemption cost by multiplying the reward value by the number of members likely to cross the threshold in a quarter. Compare that cost with the extra margin you expect from more frequent visits. Publish the threshold in plain wording, for example earn five hundred points to get a five dollar credit. Track the median time to first redemption and the share of members redeeming within ninety days, then adjust the threshold in small steps of no more than twenty percent.
Common mistakes
- Setting the first redemption threshold so high that a typical member needs more than six months to reach it, which kills early motivation and encourages points hoarding.
- Copying a threshold from another brand without checking your own margin per transaction, so each redemption reduces profit instead of building loyalty.
- Forgetting to include variable costs such as shipping, packaging, or payment fees when calculating the true cost of the reward behind a threshold.
- Changing a threshold after members have already earned points toward it without protecting existing balances, which breaks trust and may cause complaints.