Learn · Economics
Understanding breakage
Understanding breakage means recognising that a portion of issued loyalty points will never be redeemed. It allows a programme to reduce its outstanding liability and recognise that value as revenue over time, if it is highly likely members will not use the points. Tracking pattern of expirations and dormant accounts keeps the estimate grounded in real behaviour.
How it works
Breakage is the value of points that members earn but do not redeem before they expire or become unusable. When a business issues points, it records a deferred revenue liability equal to the expected cost of supplying those rewards. Over time, some members stop engaging, let points lapse, or fail to meet redemption thresholds. If the programme can reasonably estimate the portion that will never be used, it reduces the liability and recognises that amount as breakage revenue. The remaining liability then reflects only points still expected to be redeemed. This reduction must follow a consistent method and update as real redemption patterns emerge. Cash flows do not change; breakage is an accounting recognition, not new money entering the business.
Worked example
This example is illustrative arithmetic, not a real business result. A coffee shop gives 500 members 1,000 points each, so 500,000 points are issued. Each point has redemption value of 2 cents, creating an initial liability of 10,000 dollars (500,000 x 0.02). In 12 months, members redeem 350,000 points, worth 7,000 dollars. If breakage is set at 20 percent of issued points, then 100,000 points are expected never to be redeemed, worth 2,000 dollars. The ending liability is 50,000 remaining points x 0.02, or 1,000 dollars. Revenue recognised in the period is 7,000 dollars from redemptions plus 2,000 dollars from breakage, leaving 1,000 dollars still deferred.
What to do
Define clear expiry rules or inactivity thresholds for points first. Record a liability for all issued points at their redemption value. Gather actual redemption and expiry history from your loyalty register over at least several periods. Calculate the proportion of points that lapsed, expired, or went unredeemed after a fixed time. Set a breakage rate only if a stable pattern emerges from your loyalty register. Apply that rate to newly issued points to reduce the liability, and review it at least every quarter. Update the rate if actual redemptions differ from the estimate, and document the reason. In the register, separate the breakage release from normal point redemptions so reports show both components.
Common mistakes
- Treating every issued point as a permanent liability and never releasing breakage, which overstates what the business owes.
- Recognising breakage before any pattern of expirations exists, creating revenue that may later be reversed.
- Using a percentage copied from another organisation instead of measuring this programme's own member behaviour.
- Forgetting to update the breakage rate after redemption patterns change, so the liability drifts away from reality.