Learn · Measurement
When to change something
Change one loyalty programme lever only when a number you already track moves the wrong way for three consecutive months, or when a rule visibly blocks a behaviour you want. Make one change at a time, keep the rest of the programme stable, and measure the same number for three more months before adjusting again.
How it works
A loyalty programme should change one lever only after a pre-agreed indicator leaves its normal band for three consecutive months. Before launch, pick two or three observable numbers, such as monthly redemption rate, active member share, or repeat purchase rate. Define a lower and upper bound for each. A quiet week or a single complaint does not meet the condition for a rule change. When the indicator moves far enough, inspect the rule that sits nearest to the blocked action. Low redemption usually points at point cost or expiry, not at the earn rate. Low repeat purchase points at the welcome bonus or the gap before the first reward. Keep all unrelated rules fixed so the next measurement is clean. Apply any revision at a natural boundary, like the first day of a statement cycle or a catalogue refresh. If an urgent correction is required, preserve existing points under the old value for a stated period. Before the new term begins, tell members the old rule, the new rule and the date it starts, in one plain sentence. After that, leave the scheme untouched for a full measuring window of three months. Then compare the chosen indicator with its pre-change level. If it has not moved the right way, restore that lever to its prior state and test the next nearest one. Overlapping adjustments make it impossible to know which action worked.
Worked example
This is an illustrative worked example. A shop gives 10 points for each 1 dollar spent. A 10 dollar voucher costs 1,000 points. One member spends 300 dollars in a month and earns 3,000 points. At a baseline redemption rate of 20 percent, that member uses 600 points in the month. The rate then falls to 11 percent over three months, meaning only 330 of the 3,000 points are used. To remove cost friction, the shop lowers the voucher price to 800 points. The same 3,000 points now buy 3.75 vouchers, because 3,000 divided by 800 equals 3.75. In the following month the redemption rate reaches 15 percent, so the member uses 450 points, which is 120 more than 330. The cheaper voucher has cleared an obvious barrier.
What to do
Start by selecting one number that reflects desired member behaviour, such as redemption rate or active share. Next, write down the trigger band, using your own baseline and a fixed minimum for three consecutive months. Then choose the single closest adjustment from point cost, earn rate, expiry window, tier threshold, or welcome offer. Make that change at a calendar boundary and send a plain statement of the old term, the new term and the effective date. Leave all other settings alone for three further months. Finally, compare the same number with its pre-change level and either keep the adjustment or reverse it.
Common mistakes
- Reacting to one poor month before checking whether the indicator has already returned to normal.
- Reworking the earn rate and the redemption cost together, so neither decision can be judged separately.
- Extending point expiry while also adding a new sign-up bonus, which mixes two different member groups in the same test.
- Forgetting to tell active members before the new rule starts, causing avoidable complaints that look like programme failure.